Authenticity only works when what is being presented has a clear relationship with what people actually experience. Marketing can help explain and strengthen something that is already there, but it becomes risky when it starts creating a version of a place or organisation that the reality itself cannot support.
I have always found the word authentic slightly difficult in marketing. It appears everywhere these days: authentic experiences, authentic food, authentic places, authentic brands and authentic leadership. The more valuable the idea becomes, the more organisations naturally want to associate themselves with it.
Of course, I understand why. Most people do not want to feel that everything has been designed simply to sell to them. In tourism particularly, there is something attractive about arriving somewhere that has its own character and gives you a sense of the people, history or environment around it.
My concern begins when authenticity becomes something the marketing itself is expected to “create”. If an organisation starts by saying it needs to look more authentic, I think there is already a risk that the way it wants to be perceived is being considered before anyone has properly looked at what is genuinely there.
What does brand authenticity actually mean?
There are many definitions of authenticity, and the subject has been debated for years in both branding and tourism. For me, the simplest way to look at it is whether there is a clear relationship between what an organisation says it is and what somebody actually experiences.
If I have been told something about a place before I arrive and then see evidence of it when I get there, it usually improves my understanding and often my emotional attachment to that place. If the experience is actually quite different from what was presented through the marketing, the opposite can happen, and that impression can remain long after the visit itself.
I also do not think authenticity means that something has to be old, traditional, rural or untouched. A modern business can be authentic. A place can change and remain authentic. An experience can be carefully managed and still feel completely genuine. What matters is whether what is being presented has a proper relationship with what is actually there.
Greyton and its horses
Greyton, in the Overberg region of the Western Cape, is somewhere I have visited and photographed many times. It is a small town that has become increasingly popular and expensive, particularly with people who enjoy a rural way of life while still having access to many of the comforts they are used to.
There are a couple of small hotels and guest houses, restaurants, old buildings, tree-lined streets, mountains, hiking and a very particular village atmosphere. But one of the things I notice most whenever I am there is the horses.
You can walk through Greyton and find a horse grazing beside the road, standing in the park or appearing somewhere you simply would not expect to see one. They are not wild horses in the true sense of the word. They are free-roaming horses that remain connected to people and the wider community.
Greyton already promotes the horses as part of the character of the town, and that makes sense to me. Their presence is unusual and immediately noticeable. But I think there is a much bigger opportunity in understanding the relationship between the horses, the people and the place rather than simply presenting them as another attractive feature.
The history of Greyton includes horse breeding, commonage and grazing rights, although I would be careful not to suggest that the horses roaming the town today are necessarily a direct continuation of those earlier animals. What matters more to me is that horses have had a relationship with the area for a long time, and today they remain very visible in the way people experience the town. That gives the story far more depth.
The horses are not there because tourism decided they would make good photographs. They are already part of the place and its character.
Authentic does not mean perfect
Interestingly, there is another side to the horses that I think makes the story even more real.
Free-roaming animals bring problems as well as charm. There are welfare concerns, injuries, traffic, fencing, dogs and the practical difficulty of managing animals that move freely through a town and the surrounding land. From a conventional marketing point of view, it might seem easier to leave that part of the story out. A photograph of a horse quietly grazing beneath old trees is much easier to sell than a discussion about animal welfare and the difficulties of managing free-roaming horses.
I still think the fuller story is more powerful. The horses are part of a living community, and living communities are rarely perfect. Their presence creates character and an experience that I find very special, but it also creates responsibilities and problems that people have to deal with. Knowing some of that adds context when you come across a horse wandering past the local café or standing quietly beside the road.
The same applies elsewhere. A conservation project will have setbacks. A historic community may have tensions. A family business will probably have made mistakes along the way. Those things do not automatically make the story less authentic. In many cases they explain the place or organisation far better than a version where everything has been cleaned up for presentation. They give the story more depth and allow people to understand it from more than one side.
Can authenticity be marketed?
I think it can, but there is an important difference between marketing something authentic and expecting the marketing to create the authenticity itself.
If something real already exists, good communication can help people notice and understand it. Greyton's horses can be photographed, researched and explained. Visitors can be given some context before they arrive so that when they see a horse wandering through town, they understand more about what they are looking at and why it is part of the place.
Marketing has not invented the experience. It has simply helped the visitor become more aware of it and perhaps understand it better.
Communication before somebody arrives will always influence the impression and expectation they have of a destination. If that communication provides useful background, the experience can become much richer. If it creates a story that the destination itself cannot support once somebody gets there, the result can be disappointment or distrust. For me, this is where authenticity and marketing either work together or begin moving apart.
Why does authenticity matter in tourism?
Tourism relies heavily on expectation. By the time most people arrive somewhere, they have already seen photographs, websites, social posts, videos or recommendations and have some impression of what the place will be like. The visitor therefore rarely arrives completely neutral.
The way a destination presents itself influences what the visitor notices, what they expect and sometimes even what they consider important once they are there. This is also closely connected to something I explored in Who Has the Right to Tell the Story of a Place?: the story of a destination is influenced by who is telling it and what they want people to notice.
I think this is particularly important now because visitors often pay attention to more than the obvious attractions. Conservation, sustainability, local livelihoods, community involvement and the impact tourism has on a destination can all influence the way people judge a place. Authenticity therefore goes beyond whether an old building is genuinely old or whether a local tradition is still being practised. It also includes whether the wider story being presented continues to make sense when somebody begins looking more closely.
When the story and the experience no longer match
The moment an organisation starts trying too hard to look authentic, things become risky because the story can gradually move away from what the organisation or place actually is and towards what somebody believes people want it to be.
A lodge may decide conservation should sit at the centre of its identity because conservation increasingly matters to guests. A destination may promote local culture because visitors want local experiences. A company may place its founder story at the centre of its communication because personal stories create engagement. Any of those things can be completely genuine, but there still needs to be enough reality underneath the claim to support it.
If conservation is central to a lodge's identity, I would expect to see it in the way the lodge operates and not only in the photographs and words on the website. If a destination talks about its relationship with the local community, that relationship should extend beyond using people in promotional photographs. The same applies to a business claiming personal service, sustainability, heritage or craftsmanship. The story needs evidence behind it.
For me, the simplest test is whether the experience has a reasonable relationship with what I was led to expect. It does not need to match perfectly, and discovering something unexpected can often be one of the best parts of travelling. But the main story should still make sense once somebody arrives. If it does not, the problem moves beyond marketing and becomes one of trust.
Authenticity can change with the place
I also do not think the most authentic version of somewhere is necessarily the oldest version of it.
Greyton today is not Greyton in 1854 or Greyton fifty years ago. New people have moved there, property values have changed, businesses have opened, tourism has developed and the town continues to change. Those changes are part of Greyton too, so trying to freeze the place at one point in its history can become just as artificial as inventing a completely new identity for it.
I see authenticity more as the relationship between where something came from, what it is now and where it may be going. The same applies to organisations. A company can change significantly and still remain authentic if there is a clear relationship between its history, what it believes now and what it is trying to become. Holding onto an old identity simply because it appears more authentic can eventually become as artificial as creating a new one purely for marketing purposes.
Photography can create an impression of authenticity too
As a photographer, I am very aware that an image can create a strong impression of authenticity without explaining much about the wider reality.
If I photograph one of Greyton's horses standing alone in early morning light, I can create a particular mood. The image may feel rural, wild, peaceful or almost timeless. The photograph can still be completely truthful because that moment really happened, but it will not explain that the horse may have an owner, that there are welfare issues associated with free roaming or that Greyton itself is a changing and increasingly expensive town.
I do not think that means I should avoid taking the photograph. Quite the opposite. It means I need to understand what the photograph is doing. Photography is very good at creating emotional attachment, which is one reason it is so powerful in tourism. The story around the image can add context to that emotion and help somebody understand more than the photograph alone can show.
For me, that makes the photograph more useful without making it any less beautiful.
Recognising what is already there
I think some of the strongest authentic experiences are the ones that do not need to convince me very hard. Greyton's horses are a good example because they are already there. Nobody needs to put one in the road so that visitors can photograph it. Their presence already forms part of the way people experience the town.
The opportunity is to understand that properly and tell the story well. Marketing can give context, draw attention to something people might otherwise overlook and help somebody understand why an experience belongs to that particular place. It becomes risky when the process works the other way around and the marketing starts deciding what the reality needs to look like.
For me, authenticity does not need to be created by the marketing. It needs to be recognised, understood and presented in a way that remains connected to what people will actually experience.
Sources & further reading
Södergren, J. (2021). Brand Authenticity: 25 Years of Research. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 45(4), 645–663.
Morhart, F., Malär, L., Guèvremont, A., Girardin, F. & Grohmann, B. (2015). Brand Authenticity: An Integrative Framework and Measurement Scale. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 25(2), 200–218.
Rickly, J.M. (2022). A Review of Authenticity Research in Tourism: Launching the Annals of Tourism Research Curated Collection on Authenticity. Annals of Tourism Research, 92, 103349.
Jiménez-Barreto, J., Rubio, N. & Campo, S. (2020). Destination Brand Authenticity: What an Experiential Simulacrum! A Multigroup Analysis of Its Antecedents and Outcomes Through Official Online Platforms. Tourism Management, 77, 104022.
Greyton Tourism. Greyton and its free-roaming horses, village character and history. Greyton Tourism and Greyton's History. Greyton Tourism has also discussed the practical welfare challenges affecting the horses in Greyton's Free Roaming Horses at Risk.

